Disputes are inevitable. In the world of contracting, even the most well-drafted agreements can encounter friction—missed deadlines, misunderstood deliverables, unexpected costs, or performance gaps. But what separates high-performing partnerships from dysfunctional ones isn’t the absence of conflict—it’s how conflict is handled.
When a dispute arises, the instinct to point fingers is strong. Blame feels satisfying in the moment. It protects reputations, shifts responsibility, and vents frustration. But it doesn’t solve the problem. Worse, it erodes trust, poisons relationships, and derails delivery.
The alternative? Constructive resolution. A mindset and method that focuses on fixing the issue, preserving the relationship, and learning from the experience. It’s not about avoiding accountability—it’s about channeling it productively.
Here are ten tactics that successful contract managers, suppliers, and customers use to resolve disputes constructively—without assigning blame.
1. Start with a Neutral Fact-Finding Session
Before emotions escalate, gather the facts. What happened? When? Who was involved? What was the impact? Use objective data—emails, logs, reports—to build a shared understanding.
Why it works: It grounds the conversation in reality, not assumptions or accusations.
2. Convene a Joint Problem-Solving Meeting
Bring both sides together—contract managers, stakeholders, and subject matter experts. Frame the meeting as a collaboration, not a confrontation. Use a clear agenda and a neutral facilitator if needed.
Tip: Focus on outcomes, not grievances.
3. Use “We” Language Instead of “You” Language
Language shapes mindset. Replace “You failed to deliver” with “We didn’t meet the milestone—let’s explore why.” This subtle shift fosters shared ownership and reduces defensiveness.
Impact: It turns adversaries into allies.
4. Revisit the Contract Together
Contracts are more than enforcement tools—they’re reference points. Review the relevant clauses together. Clarify expectations, obligations, and remedies. Use the contract to guide—not weaponize—the conversation.
Best Practice: Focus on interpretation, not accusation.
5. Identify Root Causes, Not Just Symptoms
Don’t just fix what’s broken—understand why it broke. Use root cause analysis techniques like the “Five Whys” or fishbone diagrams. Look beyond the immediate issue to systemic factors.
Example: A missed delivery might stem from unclear specs, not poor performance.
6. Explore Multiple Solution Paths
Avoid binary thinking. Instead of “Who’s right?” ask “What are our options?” Brainstorm solutions together—adjust timelines, revise scope, offer concessions, or restructure workflows.
Tip: Use a decision matrix to evaluate trade-offs.
7. Agree on a Resolution Plan with Clear Actions
Once a path forward is chosen, document it. Who will do what, by when? What are the success criteria? How will progress be tracked? Clarity prevents future confusion.
Why it matters: Resolution without follow-through is just conversation.
8. Communicate the Resolution Internally
Don’t let rumors fill the void. Share the resolution with relevant teams—finance, legal, operations. Explain what happened, what’s being done, and what’s expected going forward.
Impact: Transparency builds trust and prevents misinformation.
9. Capture Lessons Learned
Every dispute is a learning opportunity. What could have been done differently? What signals were missed? What processes need improvement? Document insights and share them across the organization.
Best Practice: Use a post-mortem template to guide reflection.
10. Reaffirm the Relationship
End the resolution process by reaffirming the partnership. Express appreciation for collaboration. Acknowledge the effort to resolve constructively. Set the tone for future engagement.
Why it works: It turns a setback into a strengthening moment.
Final Thought: Disputes Are Inevitable. Dysfunction Is Optional.
In contracting, disputes are not a sign of failure—they’re a sign of complexity. They arise when expectations collide with reality. But how they’re handled determines whether contracts deliver value or devolve into conflict.
Constructive resolution isn’t about avoiding accountability—it’s about applying it wisely. It’s about focusing on the issue, not the ego. It’s about preserving relationships while solving problems. And it’s about turning every dispute into a chance to improve.
So here’s your call to action:
Audit your current dispute resolution practices. Are they collaborative, structured, and focused on outcomes? If not—start building the framework.
Your thoughts?
Contracting.blog 