Benchmarking Post-Award Contract Management: Why Diligence Defines Success

Jim Bergman

Contracts are not just pieces of paper; they are the lifeblood of modern business relationships. They define obligations, allocate risks, and establish frameworks for collaboration. Yet, too often, contracts are treated as static artifacts—signed, filed away, and only revisited when something goes wrong. This mindset is outdated and dangerous.

The real power of contracts is realized in the post-award phase, where agreements come to life. Post-award contract management is where obligations are fulfilled, performance is monitored, and opportunities for improvement are discovered. It is also where organizations can unlock enormous value—if they are diligent in benchmarking their effectiveness.

Benchmarking is not a luxury; it is a necessity. It provides the data, insights, and comparisons needed to ensure that contract management practices are not only compliant but also competitive, efficient, and aligned with strategic goals. Without benchmarking, organizations risk inefficiency, missed opportunities, and misalignment with customer expectations. With it, they can transform contracts from administrative burdens into strategic assets.

Why Benchmarking Matters

Benchmarking is the process of measuring performance against standards, peers, or best practices. In post-award contract management, it involves assessing how effectively contracts are managed, how well obligations are met, and how much value is created.

Why is this so important?

  • Transparency: Benchmarking provides visibility into performance, ensuring that obligations are met and risks are managed.
  • Accountability: It holds contract managers and suppliers accountable for outcomes.
  • Continuous Improvement: Benchmarking identifies gaps and opportunities for process enhancements.
  • Competitiveness: It ensures that contract management practices remain aligned with industry standards and customer expectations.
  • Strategic Alignment: Benchmarking ensures that contracts support organizational goals, from cost savings to sustainability.

In short, benchmarking transforms contract management from reactive compliance into proactive governance.

What to Benchmark

Contract managers must be diligent in benchmarking across multiple dimensions:

  • Compliance: Are obligations being met? Are regulatory requirements being fulfilled?
  • Performance: Are suppliers delivering on time, at the right quality, and within budget?
  • Risk Management: Are risks being identified, assessed, and mitigated effectively?
  • Value Creation: Are contracts delivering cost savings, innovation, and sustainability?
  • Relationship Management: Are partnerships strong, collaborative, and resilient?
  • Process Efficiency: Are contract management processes streamlined, automated, and effective?

By benchmarking across these dimensions, contract managers gain a holistic view of effectiveness.

How to Benchmark Effectively

Benchmarking is not just about collecting data; it is about using it to drive improvement. Effective benchmarking requires:

  • Clear Metrics: Define measurable outcomes for compliance, performance, risk, value, relationships, and processes.
  • Reliable Data: Collect accurate, timely, and relevant data from contracts, suppliers, and systems.
  • Comparisons: Benchmark against industry standards, peers, and best practices.
  • Analysis: Identify gaps, trends, and opportunities for improvement.
  • Action: Use insights to drive changes in processes, relationships, and strategies.

Benchmarking is a cycle of measurement, analysis, and improvement. It is not a one-time exercise; it must be embedded into post-award contract management as a continuous process.

Sector-Specific Applications

The importance of benchmarking spans industries:

  • Manufacturing: Benchmarking ensures supply chains remain resilient, efficient, and sustainable.
  • Healthcare: Benchmarking ensures compliance with patient privacy regulations and ethical sourcing standards.
  • Technology: Benchmarking ensures cybersecurity, innovation, and data privacy commitments are met.
  • Retail: Benchmarking ensures suppliers meet sustainability standards for packaging and sourcing.
  • Construction: Benchmarking ensures project success, safety compliance, and cost control.
  • Energy: Benchmarking ensures compliance with renewable energy commitments and emissions reduction.
  • Transportation: Benchmarking ensures logistics providers meet fuel efficiency and emissions targets.
  • Financial Services: Benchmarking ensures compliance with evolving regulations and ethical standards.
  • Hospitality: Benchmarking ensures service standards align with guest expectations.
  • Government: Benchmarking ensures transparency and accountability in public procurement.
  • Non-Profits: Benchmarking ensures alignment with donor expectations on sustainability.
  • Faith-Based Universities: Benchmarking ensures supplier relationships align with mission-driven values and accreditation standards.

These examples demonstrate the versatility and importance of benchmarking across diverse contexts.

Keys to Success

To succeed in benchmarking post-award contract management effectiveness, organizations must:

  • Commit Leadership Support: Senior executives must champion benchmarking.
  • Invest in Technology: Use digital tools to collect, analyze, and report data.
  • Foster a Culture of Improvement: Encourage teams to view benchmarking as an opportunity, not a burden.
  • Engage Stakeholders: Involve diverse perspectives to ensure holistic benchmarking.
  • Measure Progress: Define metrics for benchmarking and track outcomes.

Risks of Neglecting Benchmarking

Failing to benchmark post-award contract management effectiveness can lead to:

  • Compliance Failures: Ignoring regulatory changes can result in penalties.
  • Reputational Damage: Failing to meet commitments can erode trust.
  • Operational Inefficiencies: Outdated practices can increase costs and waste.
  • Relationship Strain: Misalignment with customer expectations can weaken partnerships.
  • Missed Opportunities: Neglecting benchmarking can hinder innovation and competitiveness.

The risks are too great to ignore. Benchmarking is essential for success in modern contract management.

Energizing the Future of Contract Management

The future of contract management is collaborative, adaptive, and sustainability-driven. Organizations that embrace benchmarking as a key enabler of post-award effectiveness will be better positioned to:

  • Respond to market shifts with agility.
  • Innovate faster and more effectively.
  • Build resilient supply chains.
  • Meet evolving customer and stakeholder expectations.
  • Create sustainable, long-term value.

Those that cling to outdated, transactional approaches will find themselves constrained, reactive, and vulnerable. The choice is clear: benchmarking, or stagnation.

Conclusion and Call to Action

Contracts are not just legal documents—they are frameworks for relationships and performance. In the post-award phase, the true potential of contracts is realized when professionals move beyond compliance and embrace collaboration. Benchmarking is essential for success, providing the data, insights, and comparisons needed to drive sustainability, innovation, and resilience.

The benefits are undeniable: agility, efficiency, innovation, resilience, and customer alignment. The risks are manageable with clear processes, strong governance, open communication, flexibility, and measurement. And the applications span industries, from manufacturing to healthcare to faith-based universities.

The message is simple: post-award contract management is not about enforcing obligations—it’s about creating shared value and driving success.

Call to Action: Audit your current benchmarking practices. Identify gaps in compliance, performance, risk management, value creation, relationship management, and process efficiency. Invest in technology, foster a culture of improvement, and commit to benchmarking as a continuous process.

The future of contract management belongs to those who embrace benchmarking. Don’t wait for inefficiencies or disruptions to force change—start benchmarking your post-award contract management effectiveness today, and unlock the full potential of your supplier-customer relationships.

Your thoughts?

Unknown's avatar

Published by Jim Bergman

Jim Bergman is a commercial contract professional with global experience spanning the USA, Latin America, UK, Europe, China, South Korea, Japan, India, SE Asia, the Middle East, Africa and Australia. He has worked on a wide range of direct and indirect spend categories in numerous sectors, developing a deep knowledge of services, goods and technology procurement and sales. Across this wide array of commodity and services experience, Jim has found the keys to success in maximizing value for money through customer-supplier relationships founded on innovative category management and strategic sourcing practices, key performance metrics and measures, as well as Total Cost of Ownership principles and collaborative contracting tenets. He has shared his knowledge through advisory engagements, as well as in developing and delivering training programs both on-line and in classrooms, in both open-enrollment and internal environments. Jim has assisted his clients through all phases and steps of contracting, negotiation, strategic sourcing and bidding processes, demonstrating value generation in excess of $250 million. His audiences and clients have included over 7,000 attorneys and commercial professionals students from over 1,000 corporations and public-sector entities.

Leave a comment